It was supposed to be Eighties week on American Idol, but the eight remaining semifinalist guys embraced the night’s other theme: embarrassment. 80s is that decade where stuff that went down really embarrasses you now, LOL! As per the Rolling Stones,

“Luke Menard sang a wussy “Wake Me Up Before You Go-Go,” David Hernandez recalled the dreadful day he had “a pea-sized booger” in his nose and even wunderkind David Archuleta had to swallow his pride as Simon Cowell called his Phil Collins cover “gloomy”.”

Per Canada.com,

“Simon gave David Archuleta cred for showing nerve, but when the manchild followed up this week with Phil Collins’ ‘Another Day in Paradise’ — again, not as awful as it sounds — Simon’s notoriously thin patience began to show. Too much of a downer, dude, Simon said, though not in so many words. How old are you, 17? Show some lightness, dude, it doesn’t have to be dark all the time.”

So David Archuleta fans, what do you think?? Did our darling picked the wrong song this week? If yes, PLEASE STILL VOTE!!! Hehe! He may be up to something spectacular next week! ;-p

One writer advices American Idol’s current tween sensation “to bomb one of these early weeks.” The writer explains, “For some reason, ‘Idol’ history shows that the more flawless someone (like David Archuleta) appears to be early on, the harder they fall later for the tiniest mess-up. If he’s too perfect up until the top four or top three, and then gives a subpar performance that week, ‘Idol’ past suggests he’ll have a huge target on his back.”
Another writer agrees and thinks our darling David Archuleta isn’t without his weaknesses.

“Nobody likes a contestant to peak too early on ‘Idol,’ ” he said. “It sort of takes the fun out of it for viewers if it becomes a 15-week coronation march for him. I think there will be moments where the judges are tough on him, maybe even overly tough on him, because I don’t think they want this season to be a forgone conclusion before we reach the final 12.” Hmmm, I quite agree with the both of them! Let’s see how David Archuleta fares this week!

Writers who follow American Idol are giving unsolicited (but heartfelt) analysis of AI’s current teen sensation. One writer pointed out, “Peaking this early could come back to haunt David Archuleta. People may tire of the ‘aw shucks’ thing, and his ‘prior experience’ might eventually turn people off … I read a few upset comments about how he ‘recycled’ his ‘Imagine’ performance from a local Utah talk show after a clip popped up on YouTube.” Michael Slezak, a senior writer for Entertainment Weekly who has become known for his American Idol coverage, agrees with the previous writer.

He says, “I think at this point calling David Archuleta the ‘early front-runner’ would be an understatement. He’s that cuddly, cute contestant that tweens and grandmas alike can get behind, and that’s a pretty powerful voting bloc. We’ve seen what … Kevin Covais did in the competition without being particularly great vocalists, just on the cute, teen merits alone, that I think this kid has that plus — what we’ve seen so far — a pretty good singing voice.” Mr. Slezak further added, “I don’t know if I’m ready to call it a great singing voice yet. It’s too early to hand him the competition, but on the other hand, if someone said bet all your money on one contestant to win, it would be David Archuleta.” WOW!!!